Editorial: Are morals affordable in an economic downturn?

 

The ad industry's moral compass has always been an imperfect navigational aid.

Tony Davidson and Kim Papworth

Tony Davidson and Kim Papworth

The best work from the W&K creative team

Creative poses

Creative poses

Top London creatives strike a pose for D&AD New Blood

And if you accept Andrew Cracknell's argument on page 28, it's becoming ever more unreliable. It's not that the agency establishment doesn't accept that power and responsibility go hand in hand. Not least because it would be commercial suicide for any advertiser to blatantly overstep moral boundaries.

Nevertheless, agreement on what is and isn't principled behaviour by agencies becomes harder to define. In less sophisticated times, many had firm rules about not accepting tobacco or political accounts. David Ogilvy's famous 60s dictum about never running an ad you would not want your own family to see seemed a good creed by which to live.

While there will always be cases where the moral issue at stake is black or white, adland is now having to confront cases where doing the right thing is far from clear-cut.

And it's possible agencies will find themselves increasingly caught in the crossfire of an ethical battle in which the high moral ground is hard to locate. For example, to what extent should an agency satisfy itself about a client's green credentials before it agrees to promote them?

Also, what is and what isn't harmful to the environment may depend on where in the world you live. Not buying Kenyan runner beans to cut back on food miles may seem like principled behaviour in Hampstead. Impoverished Kenyan vegetable-growers are unlikely to agree.

What's beyond question is that the harsh economic climate will test agencies' morality to the limit. Word is that many are already battling to win the experiential and field marketing brief for the tobacco manufacturer Gallaher.

A principle isn't a principle until it costs you money, Bill Bernbach famously observed. It remains to be seen how many agencies will emerge from the turbulence with both their balance sheets and their morals in good shape.

X

You must log in to use Clip & Save

 
 

Email this article to a friend

Items with an asterisk * are required

Cancel
 
 
 

Email Bulletins

You can sign up here for our email bulletins. Enter your email address, select the bulletins you are interested in and click Subscribe.

Preview
Preview
Preview
 

Christmas ads 2009

Christmas ads 2009

View this year's crop of festive ads

ADdicts cartoons

ADdicts cartoons

Gallery of cartoons published each week in Campaign

Public View

Public View

What does the public think of the latest ads?

Viral View

Viral View

Best of the latest ad virals

Promotion - Integration Essays

Promotion - Integration Essays

Watch videos of Integration Essays 2009 contributors

Campaign Awards Fight

Campaign Awards Fight

Pit two industry creatives against each other

House of Cards

House of Cards

Gallery of images from Leo Burnett's Shelter exhibition

 

In Print

Cover Latest issue: 12 March 2010Subscribe
 

Poll

Will 2009 go down as the year media sold itself short?