Adwatch (July 27): Top 20 recall - Persil all washed out?
By Toby Horry, Managing partner, Dare, marketingmagazine.co.uk, Wednesday, 27 July 2011 12:00AM
The fault here is not the ad itself, but the rather average content that it directs you to.
Unless you've been living under a rock for the past decade, you'll know that the world of marketing has changed; media-neutral, integrated comms, ideation, imagineering, blah, blah, blah.
It really comes down to one thing: people don't care as much about ads as they used to. Therefore, I applaud the intent of brands such as Persil, which are attempting to create experiences (through content, services, games) people feel are genuinely worth their attention.
However, I detect that the Persil ad highlights the single biggest error that brands and agencies make when taking this approach. In it we see Kirstie 'I wasn't born, I was knitted' Allsopp with her (alleged) children creating an indoor herb garden in just 30 minutes, as this is how little time it takes for Persil 'Small & Mighty' to do its thing. Of course, in the process of creating said garden, the kids get all mucky, and thus another dose of Persil is required; spot-on for the overarching and brilliant 'Dirt is good' strategy.
The ad also uses media placement to ensure that we see the 'before' herb garden ad half an hour prior to seeing Kirstie's garden in all its coiffed glory.
At the end of the ad we are invited to go to persil.co.uk/minimiracles for 'great tips on creating your own indoor herb garden and other ideas'.
The ad itself is unremarkable, but I would argue that this shouldn't matter if the online content that you are directed to proves to be compelling and rewarding.
This content is what should deliver incremental media value and advocacy. Sadly, in this instance, at the site you are presented only with a bread recipe, instructions on how to make a herb garden, and a competition to win a year's supply of Persil. The word 'afterthought' doesn't quite cover it.
It feels unfair to pick on Persil as it is by no means the only brand to have taken this approach. Indeed, I hold my hand up and admit I have committed this very crime.
It does highlight, however, that if you want to provide an experience for consumers and make a TV ad to drive people to it, you need to work out the genuinely compelling experience first and the TV ad second. You also need to spend at least as much time and money developing the experience as you do the TV ad that talks about it.
I still cite the Walkers 'Do us a flavour' campaign as one where it was done right. I can't really remember the TV ad for that campaign, but the idea at the heart of it was so strong that it doesn't matter.
|Adwatch (July 27): Top 20 recall|
|2||(–)||Walkers Crisps||Abbott Mead Vickers BBDO/OMD UK||45|
|3=||(–)||BT||Abbott Mead Vickers BBDO/Maxus||39|
|3=||(–)||Asda||Saatchi & Saatchi/Carat||39|
|5||(–)||National Lottery – EuroMillions||Abbott Mead Vickers BBDO/OMD UK||35|
|6||(14=)||L'Oreal – Revitalist Repair 10||
|7=||-5||McDonald's||Leo Burnett/OMD UK||32|
|7=||(–)||InjuryLawyers4U||The Gate Films/MediaCom North||32|
|11=||(–)||Tesco||The Red Brick Road/Initiative||29|
|11=||(–)||Burger King||Crispin Porter & Bogusky/Initiative||29|
|11=||(–)||Tampax||Leo Burnett Milan/Starcom||29|
|15=||(–)||Expedia||Ogilvy & Mather/PHD||26|
Euro RSCG London/
|20||(–)||Nikon Coolpix S9100||Jung Von Matt, DCH/MediaCom||21|
This article was first published on marketingmagazine.co.uk
- Marketing Manager Fidelity Worldwide Investment Dependent on Experience, Surrey
- Senior Sales Executive- Fashion & Beauty Video Ultimate Asset £27000 - £35000 per annum + commission and benefits , City of London
- Sales Manager - Ad-tech, Content, Video and Programmatic Ultimate Asset £35000 - £45000 per annum + commission & excellent benefits, London
- Head of Fundraising Brand Recruitment £40000 per annum, Peterborough
- Digital Designer Creative Recruitment £25000 - £35000 per annum, London