Richard Desmond wins out against Camelot

Camelot today (22 August) suffered a defeat in the High Court over an action in which it accused the lotteries watchdog of failing in its legal duty to protect it from Richard Desmond's Health Lottery.

Richard Desmond: launched the Health Lottery in October last year
Richard Desmond: launched the Health Lottery in October last year

The High Court maintained that Camelot's legal challenge had failed because of "its failure to establish claims with a real prospect of success" and it had also been undermined by delays in seeking the judicial review.

Camelot, which operates the National Lottery, had been trying to persuade the High Court that the Gambling Commission had been wrong to award Desmond a licence to operate the Health Lottery.

It wanted the commission to revoke the Health Lottery's licences, as it claimed the lottery contravened the 2005 Gambling Act.

Specifically, Camelot claimed the Health Lottery – which promotes draws on behalf of 51 organisations and charities – was not a collection of single lotteries, but had become a rival to the National Lottery. It claimed that the Health Lottery was impacting on Camelot's revenues

Camelot called for the High Court review after the Gambling Commission's decision not to uphold its complaints against the Health Lottery.

In his ruling, Lord Justice Stanley Burnton concluded: "I would refuse Camelot permission to proceed with its claim for judicial review, on the grounds of its delay and its failure to establish a claim with a real prospect of success. I would refuse it permission to amend its claim on the ground that its amended claim has no real prospect of success.

"I agree with the Commission that the question whether multiple society lotteries should be permitted is a political question, to be determined by the Government or Parliament. Multiple society lotteries are not prohibited by the Act"

Responding to the verdict, Camelot said it was "disappointed" by the decision and said it would appeal to the Court of Appeal.

Subscribe to Campaign from just £57 per quarter

Includes weekly and quarterly print issues, plus unrestricted online access.

SUBSCRIBE

Looking for a new job?

Get the latest creative jobs in advertising, media, marketing and digital delivered directly to your inbox each day.

Create an Alert Now
Look out for the invisibles and introverts in your agency
Share

1 Look out for the invisibles and introverts in your agency

By cultivating a clubbable culture, agencies are ostracising talented introverts, writes Andy Jex, the executive creative director at Saatchi & Saatchi London.

Brexit reaction: Ad industry rocked by UK vote to leave EU
Shares0
Share

1 Brexit reaction: Ad industry rocked by UK vote to leave EU

Senior figures from across the UK's advertising industry have reacted with shock and dismay after the country voted to leave the European Union.

Just published