Reality check - September 2012

Adam & Eve/DDB's latest spot for John Lewis was the most-liked ad of September and also managed to garner a healthy percentage of online conversations about advertising. Otherwise, there was precious little crossover between ads that were remembered by viewers and those that were liked or chatted about online.

Colgate: most-remembered ad in September
Colgate: most-remembered ad in September

Samsung won entries in two tables, while Aldi continued its run of making at least one of the tables with a cheese-related spot from McCann Manchester. It was Colgate, though, with a former Campaign Turkey of the Week, that attracted the highest recall among consumers, according to data from Nielsen and NM Incite.

The "most-remembered" score is the percentage of viewers who can recall within 24 hours the storyline of an ad. These scores are indexed against a mean score for all new ads, with 100 representing the mean. The "most-liked" score is the percentage of viewers who liked a spot indexed against the mean score of 100.


Reality Check September 2012

Most-remembered ads


Most-liked ads


Most-talked-about ads online

1 Colgate 164 1 John Lewis
157 1 Misguided 14.97
  'focus group'
    'the other half'
    'high summer'
  Y&R Paris
    Adam & Eve/DDB
    The Gate Films
2 Ryvita 157 2 Lindt 143 2 Samsung Galaxy 4.49
  'soup'     'so thin, so intense'
    'the next big thing'
  Grey London
    Leo Burnett
3 Aldi 152 2 Sky
143 3 John Lewis
    'Bruce Willis'
    'the other half'
    Adam & Eve/DDB
3 Oreo 152 4 Marks &
135 4 John Frieda
  'best friends'
    'for every
woman you are'
5 Kellogs
141 4 Samsung
135 5 Walkers 1.60
  'Sue'      'the new way'
    'giant ridge'  
  Leo Burnett
    Cheil Worldwide
    AMV BBDO  

Source: Nielsen TV Brand Effect and NM Incite. Only new ads airing 1-30 September 2012. Minimum sample = 150.


Subscribe to Campaign from just £57 per quarter

Includes the weekly magazine and quarterly Campaign IQ, plus unrestricted online access.


Looking for a new job?

Get the latest creative jobs in advertising, media, marketing and digital delivered directly to your inbox each day.

Create an Alert Now

1 How Sainsbury's ads revolutionised the UK's food culture

Abbott Mead Vickers' press ads for Sainsbury's in the 1980s formed the most influential and culturally significant campaign the UK has ever produced, argues Paul Burke.

Just published