Vodafone ad banned over misleading emergency services claims

Vodafone has been censured by the ad watchdog after complaints from rival Telefonica that it misleadingly claimed in a campaign that it is used by 77% of the UK's emergency services.

Vodafone: ASA bans ad over misleading claims about usage by the emergency services
Vodafone: ASA bans ad over misleading claims about usage by the emergency services

A TV ad (below), by Grey London, featured a firefighter’s wife leaving a voicemail as he tackles a blaze, while a press ad showing a police officer and a dog carried the text, "We are honoured 77% of the emergency services use Vodafone."

O2-owner Telefonica complained on four issues, including that the campaign misleadingly implied that 77% of emergency services employees used Vodafone in a personal, not professional, capacity, and that the basis of the claim was not clear.

Vodafone argued it had collaborated with Kable, a public sector market intelligence firm, to calculate that it had billed 77% of the UK’s emergency services for use of its services – although the brand acknowledged the range of services "varied greatly" from authority to authority.

The brand added that by featuring real-life fire-fighters, and highlighting the "personal and emotional pressure" that they endure, it hoped to "demonstrate the strength of emergency services personnel".

However, the Advertising Standards Authority ruled that viewers of the TV ad were likely to understand that a voicemail from a fireman’s wife is likely to be sent using a personal phone, as opposed to a phone provided by an employer.

It also noted that the brand did not offer a definition for its claim, "77% of the emergency services use Vodafone," which could lead to an "ambiguity" that it provides exclusive telephony services to over three-quarters of the emergency services.

The ASA told Vodafone that the ad must not appear again in its current form. 

Subscribe to Campaign from just £57 per quarter

Includes the weekly magazine and quarterly Campaign IQ, plus unrestricted online access.

SUBSCRIBE

Looking for a new job?

Get the latest creative jobs in advertising, media, marketing and digital delivered directly to your inbox each day.

Create an Alert Now
Sainsbury's moves £60m ad account to Wieden & Kennedy
Share

1 Sainsbury's moves £60m ad account to Wieden & Kennedy

Sainsbury's has moved its £60m advertising account into Wieden & Kennedy, ending its 35-year-relationship with Abbott Mead Vickers BBDO.

The top 10 brands favoured by Remainers and Brexiters
Shares0
Share

1 The top 10 brands favoured by Remainers and Brexiters

Marketers can learn about our divided nation by examining the brands that appeal across the voting referendum voting split, says Emily James, chief strategy officer at Rainey Kelly Campbell Roalfe/Y&R.

Just published