OPINION: Stuart Elliott in America

By STUART ELLIOTT, the advertising columnist at The New York Times, campaignlive.co.uk, Friday, 13 July 2001 12:00PM

"Welcome to my nightmare", the shock rocker Alice Cooper sang back

in 1975. Who could have imagined more than a quarter-century later that

his anthem - yes, dear readers of a tender age, Alice was and is a he -

would be an appropriate theme song for Madison Avenue to be screaming

out to the rest of the advertising world?

For months, the hope was that the slowdown in ad spending that began

late last year in the United States could be avoidable, and avoided,


If the dotcoms outside America never grew as big and as fast as the ones

that collapsed so quickly and destructively from Silicon Valley to

Silicon Alley, the theory went, the remaining ad markets - or at least

the large, important ones such as Asia Pacific and Western Europe -

would sidestep the carnage.

But American misery is sure finding foreign company, as one giant

overseas agency after another is suddenly reporting shortfalls in

revenues and profits.

The most recent bombshells came from the Aegis Group and Havas

Advertising, which both disclosed on 5 July that as clients spent less,

their growth in revenues had slowed substantially. In America, 4 July is

Independence Day, which made 5 July Dependence Day, in that national

economies are now so dependent on each other.

Both Aegis and Havas reported slower growth (but still growth, mind

you), certainly not a reversal in results at either into negative


But, these days, any disappointing announcement, even when the signs are

still pluses instead of minuses, prompts a massive sell-off in shares,

and it was no different for Aegis and Havas: down in just one day by 20

per cent and 9.3 per cent, respectively.

That double whammy echoed the one-two punch that Wall Street inflicted

on 15 June to Interpublic and True North Communications (a week before

the Interpublic takeover of True North took effect).

When both agency companies warned analysts that cutbacks in client

spending would result in second-quarter earnings falling short of

previous estimates, Interpublic shares plunged 14.6 per cent, while True

North shares fell a bit farther, down 14.9 per cent.

The bad news has now spread to the Cordiant Communications Group, which

reduced its underlying growth projections for 2001 and saw its shares

pummelled by 10 per cent in a day; as well as to the WPP Group, which

tallied organic revenue growth in the first five months of the year of

just under 4 per cent, compared with 6 per cent in the first


The WPP words of woe were particularly, well, woeful, because they

indicated that marketing services outside the realm of traditional

advertising - supposedly immune, or at least more resistant, to client

budget cutbacks - are weakening too.

"It now appears that there are virtually no disciplines nor geographic

regions that are not impacted by the slowdown in marketing spend," David

McMurry, the advertising industry analyst for Credit Suisse First Boston

in New York, wrote in a report released the same day as the Aegis-Havas

double-dip of disappointment.

Or as Martha Reeves and the Vandellas warned ten years before Alice

Cooper's not-so-welcoming ditty: "Nowhere to run, baby, nowhere to


This article was first published on campaignlive.co.uk


You must log in to use Clip & Save

Before commenting please read our rules for commenting on articles.

If you see a comment you find offensive, you can flag it as inappropriate. In the top right-hand corner of an individual comment, you will see 'flag as inappropriate'. Clicking this prompts us to review the comment. For further information see our rules for commenting on articles.

comments powered by Disqus

Additional Information

Campaign Jobs