THE CLIENT CATALYSTS: Charles Dunstone - By relying on a handful of favourite agencies, Dunstone has been able to get the advertising he wants

By MATTHEW COWEN, campaignlive.co.uk, Friday, 30 November 2001 12:00PM

It's no secret that Charles Dunstone enjoys working with people

that he knows. As the chairman and chief executive of Carphone

Warehouse, his agency roster includes three advertising honchos that

he's known for years. There's Johnny Hornby, the founder of Clemmow

Hornby Inge, who handles TV advertising, Mike Hellens at Matters Media,

who sorts out buying, and Andy Tilley at Unity, who advises on planning.

Add to that Radioville, which has handled his radio advertising for

years, and Carphone Warehouse marketing summits begin to take on a very

old boy air.



This shouldn't really come as a surprise. Dunstone has always done

things this way and who can blame him. He started his first business

with two school friends - both of whom have gone on to be big successes.

One of them was Johnny Vaughan. The other, David Ross, opted to work on

Dunstone's second business - a two-man operation selling mobile phones

that has since made them both multi-millionaires.



Carphone Warehouse is arguably the UK's greatest business success of the

past decade - and Dunstone is its most spectacular entrepreneur. The

irony is that his brand has become one of the most recognisable in the

country despite no longer describing what his company actually does.

Dunstone's European operation, which now extends to 15 countries, is

branded the Phone House, but there's no question of making that change

in the UK.



"I'm not sure what we'd get out of rebranding," he says with typical

self-assurance. "They're inappropriate words but when we do research

people don't think carphones or warehouses. It's just a name. It's very

expensive to do it and for me there's always been something better to

spend the money on."



Refusal to splash out on a Consignia-style rebranding is far from the

only area in which Dunstone flies against latest marketing trends. It's

not that he sets out to break any advertising rules per se. It's just

that he's relentlessly shaped the way his company is sold around his own

personal judgments. His confidence in these has defined the agency

arrangements he's put in place - and those he plans for the future.



"I've always been cynical of people who said they could do everything,"

he says of his refusal to appoint a single, integrated shop. "So when we

started using radio I quite quickly worked out that if you went to a big

agency and asked them to do a radio ad for you, they didn't actually

write it. They gave it to a com-pany that wrote it such as Eardrum or

Commercial Breaks or someone that basically made them for the agency. So

immediately I cut out the middleman."



Carphone Warehouse's success is, of course, intimately linked with

radio, where it advertised at first through Eardrum and since with

Commercial Breaks, now rechristened Radioville.



It's been a profitable relationship for all concerned. The Radio

Advertising Bureau still uses the company as a case study for building a

brand on radio and Dunstone continues to enthuse about the medium's

value to his operation.



"The thing about radio that I like is that it does two jobs," he

begins.



"We used it very effectively to drive immediate sales but, at the same

time, it was working hard with the Stereo MC's sonic logo to build a

brand.



"People think we're a bigger advertiser than we are because we dominate

a particular medium and don't spread ourselves too thin. We own radio

now and we know from research that if our competitors advertise on

radio, people just think it's Carphone Warehouse. We own the

medium."



Given such domination of the traditional airwaves, it's tempting to see

Dunstone's move into TV advertising as the prestige icing on an already

wholesome marketing cake. He agrees - up to a point. "Traditionally it

has been because we've always had more effective radio ads than TV ads,"

he says. "But I think that's probably changed this time because what

we're running on TV at the moment is propelling us into a different

position in the marketplace in a way that radio perhaps couldn't have

done. For the first time it's really at the heart of what we're

doing."



This strategic move towards TV brand ads has come in response to a

fundamental shift in the mobile phone market itself. The category's

sales are down approximately 40 per cent year on year in the UK, with

operators such as Vodafone squeaking under pressure and forced to admit

that many of their customers no longer use their handsets.



Amid this general gloom, Carphone Warehouse recently saw its own share

price drop sharply, despite an impressive leap in market share from 12

to 18 per cent over the past six months. Dunstone doesn't appear overly

concerned.



"The City gives you a tick for what you should have done in the past six

months and that's a reasonably brief conversation," he says. "What they

want to know is what's going to happen in the next six months and the

next year. Quite a few people want to take a view over Christmas, which

is fair enough. It's a very important trading period for us."



Dunstone's confidence stems from a belief that his brand positioning has

readjusted to the changing market in time - just. "For someone like us,

the majority of our business is replacement sales, people who already

have a mobile but want a new or different one. We've repositioned our

business to work in that environment rather than a race for acquisition

and that's very much what we're trying to articulate in our present

advertising," he says.



"The new campaign is about your ongoing relationship with the phone. For

young people especially, the mobile represents everything about their

control of their own personal life. It's taken on an amazing importance

emotionally, because of what it allows them to do. It has taken us a

long time to realise this."



Dunstone is commendably frank about the time it has taken for his TV

advertising to hit the right notes - and noticeably generous when

allocating responsibility for the delay. After making it a point of

principle to be involved at every stage of a campaign's development, he

won't consider shifting responsibility for previous ads that haven't hit

the nail on the head.



"Even with us all working amazingly hard, it's still effectively taken

us two years to get to something that really works," he admits.



"But we've been integrated with the process so when we went the wrong

way that was as much down to us as to the agency. It wasn't them saying

'we've looked at the research and this is what you need to do,' it was

much more collaborative than that."



The experience of struggling to crack a brief is unlikely to put

Dunstone off the idea of advertising itself. He doesn't question his

media spend and points out that his agencies' fees represent a tiny

proportion of the overall budget.



"The reason the advertising world can be the way it is is because, as a

proportion of the media spend, it's still relatively small," he

says.



However, there's no doubt that Dunstone, whose workaholic habits are

well documented, views the industry as a whole with a bemused

toleration.



It's a view that's only been intensified by his own experiences of

taking his brand into TV. He first appointed Young & Rubicam back in

August 1999 before the arrival of Virgin Mobile saw his account dropped

because of conflict reasons.



"I think advertising is the most competitive area of business I've ever

seen in terms of how people fight but it's also, in many ways, the most

wasteful and least responsive business in terms of how agencies run

themselves," he says. "The way they spend on expenses and do all these

other things is absolutely astonishing to people who work in a business

like ours. We just watch slightly astonished at times."



To Dunstone, an agency shouldn't be trusted to simply get on with

things.



He believes in devoting time and effort to getting the most out of his

account.



"Sometimes the process doesn't seem to work if you get a really big

client which is quite hands off and leaves things to the agency," he

explains.



"You've got to put as much effort in yourself as they do if you want to

make sure that they understand the marketplace and what matters to you

and what you're like.



"It's no good having some management consultancy work out what you

should do and then somehow flick that to an agency and have them make an

ad," he continues, proving that his cynicism about marketing services

applies to adland's rivals as much as to itself.



In many ways, Dunstone sees his own sector as having specific needs that

traditional account handling structures might struggle to

accommodate.



"The problem was that the market was moving very quickly and there was

very little understanding of who was buying mobile phones and why they

were buying them," he says.



"If you did some research it would probably be out of date in six months

because it was such a fast-changing category. If you just applied

traditional thinking about selling jeans or cars, then it wouldn't

work."



Dunstone's suspicions about agencies' ability to come to terms with his

brief ensured that he would seek out an account handler that he already

knew. Hornby, the then joint managing director at TBWA/London, was the

beneficiary. "We never really had a pitch or anything," Dunstone

explains.



"We just got to know Johnny and Simon (Clemmow) and because of that

personal relationship, I had the feeling we wouldn't be slipped down the

TBWA organisation. They displayed a sense of personal ownership."



That sense of personal ownership was doubtless increased by the decision

of Clemmow and Hornby to break away from TBWA in April - starting

Clemmow Hornby Inge in an office space above Carphone Warehouse's

Marylebone Road store, with Dunstone as a member of the agency's

advisory board.



The move would seem to fit perfectly with Dunstone's model of working

with smaller, dedicated shops. However, he firmly denies that he

encouraged the split.



"I think I said to Johnny that I was very worried about the economy and

that it was probably the most dangerous time to do a breakaway," he

says, laughing. "But they'd emotionally checked out. They were going to

do it."



The advantages of smaller, leaner agencies are not restricted to

creative shops in Dunstone's book. It would be easy to put his choice of

media agencies down to old boy favouritism, but he insists there is

method here too. "I believe that people will do deals with us that they

wouldn't do with a big agency because Mike doesn't have any other really

big clients," he says of the media agency Matters Media. "If they did

such a good deal with a big agency, then they'd expect that for all

their clients."



Dunstone has succeeded in creating a roster of UK agencies, convincingly

devoted to his business, that overrides his own concerns about adland in

general. But can this cosy set-up survive the expansion of Carphone

Warehouse itself? When I put it to him that a burgeoning international

presence would seem to suggest the need for a traditional network, his

sides almost split.



Dunstone will adapt work produced in London to foreign markets, but

he'll do it with agencies recommended by his operations in those

countries - not with shops recommended by a network account handler in

London.



"I think I'm just a bit cynical about the world of advertising," he

says, putting it mildly. "So we've always fought very hard to try and

get it on our agenda and not get sucked into the whole process in the

way a lot of people do.



"I think the big companies that want agencies to do everything end up

getting the ad agencies that they deserve. They're huge, big

bureaucratic organisations and that's what they're going to get in their

agency."



INTIMATE DETAILS

Lives: Holland Park. "Well, it's almost Shepherd's Bush."

Car: Mercedes SL 500. "It's four years old, though."

Family: None. "I'm single."

Relaxing: Sailing.

Favourite TV: The Sweeney. "I saw it on cable TV the other day. It's

fantastic."

Favourite ad of all time: The Apple "think different" campaign with John

Lennon and Gandhi. "There was also a fantastic ad for Saturn cars which

I saw in America where this girl was being patronised by horrible

salesmen who'd only show her the vanity mirror."

Dream job: "On one level, I'd like to be prime minister because there

are several things that don't work that I'd like to put right. I'm quite

a big fan of the current one, though."



This article was first published on campaignlive.co.uk

X

You must log in to use Clip & Save

Before commenting please read our rules for commenting on articles.

If you see a comment you find offensive, you can flag it as inappropriate. In the top right-hand corner of an individual comment, you will see 'flag as inappropriate'. Clicking this prompts us to review the comment. For further information see our rules for commenting on articles.

comments powered by Disqus

Additional Information

Campaign Jobs