MEDIA: FORUM; Is a lack of creativity harming radio as a whole?

Speaking at the annual Radio Festival last week, Rupert Howell delivered a scathing attack on creativity in radio advertising. He maintains that good ads are extremely rare and that this isn’t only embarrassing for agencies but potentially damaging for the health of the medium. Is he right on both counts? Alasdair Reid reports

Speaking at the annual Radio Festival last week, Rupert Howell delivered

a scathing attack on creativity in radio advertising. He maintains that

good ads are extremely rare and that this isn’t only embarrassing for

agencies but potentially damaging for the health of the medium. Is he

right on both counts? Alasdair Reid reports



A major advertiser recently asked a researcher to phone each of the top

20 advertising agencies and request their radio reels. Only two

responded. The advertiser in question - which didn’t reveal its identity

to any of the agencies, for obvious reasons - was rather confused and

disappointed by this. It needn’t have been - for most creative

departments, radio is such a low-flier that it drops off the radar

completely.



That’s not to say that none of them ever produces excellent radio work.

Some do. And good radio work often forms part of an agency’s overall

creative credentials. It’s just that agencies don’t automatically

showcase their radio work as they do TV or press or posters - it’s the

work that they are least proud of.



There are obvious reasons for this. After all, it’s the only non-visual

medium. Radio executions can’t adorn the walls of an agency reception or

be reviewed in the pages of Campaign, so they form no part of the

currency of creative peer group rivalry. A radio campaign is the

creative department short straw, a task often handed to young teams

cutting their teeth.



Does this matter? Radio campaigns may be charmless, but they must work

because clients keep coming back for more. The medium continues to grow,

not just in absolute terms but in terms of share of UK display revenue.

It could reach its target of 5 per cent by the end of this year, up from

4.3 per cent in 1995.



It does matter, according to Rupert Howell, a managing partner at Howell

Henry Chaldecott Lury. In a hard-hitting speech to the annual Radio

Festival last week, Howell said that third-rate creativity is a major

problem. ‘If this doesn’t start improving soon, it really will limit the

growth and the popularity of the sector,’ he maintained.



‘Great radio ads are much too few and far between. In fact, you can

easily be tempted to switch off the radio altogether sometimes, as you

are slowly driven insane by the endless repetition of appalling

commercials. My favourite one at the moment is on Heart FM and is for

double glazing. It features the immortal line, ‘the only catch is on the

windows’.’



Howell believes that lessons could be learned from the poster industry,

which was equally unfashionable in creative circles 30 years ago. Then

came Collett Dickenson Pearce’s Benson and Hedges ‘gold pack’ campaign.

Its success, both commercially and creatively, was marketed

remorselessly by the medium and it became fashionable. Radio, he said,

had missed similar opportunities.



Doug MacArthur, managing director of the Radio Advertising Bureau,

admits there is something in what Howell says. ‘What the RAB has focused

on to date is the rational side of things,’ he says. ‘We’ve been

educating people about the facts and figures side of radio. And it has

worked - we have helped to increase radio revenue. That phase is almost

at an end. The next real change won’t come from the rational side of

things - it will come from encouraging an emotional like of the medium.’



MacArthur points out that creative quality has always been one of the

RAB’s concerns - albeit on a rather piecemeal basis. ‘We have awards

already, of course, and we have encouraged creativity on an isolated

tactical basis. All of that has been valuable but now we must build it

all into a serious plan. The reappearance of this topic is timely

because radio needs galvanising in this area.



‘But Howell is absolutely wrong to say that there is no good work out

there. It’s there, but we need to highlight that fact more consistently.

We also need to help make it sexier for creatives - the good thing, too,

is that clients are being more demanding these days.’



Greg Delaney, the creative director of Delaney Fletcher Bozell, agrees

that creative departments have been losing interest in radio. ‘Having

said that, the trouble with this sort of attack is that it’s a bit like

attacks on declining moral standards - it presupposes that things were

better in a golden age not so long ago. I doubt whether there ever was a

golden age,’ he says.



‘There is good work around but the perception problem comes from the

fact that there haven’t been any great campaigns as opposed to isolated

work. Great campaigns are important because they help to create

sustained interest and raise the profile of the medium. That always

affects attitudes in the creative department - creatives tend to want to

go where the fashion is.



‘Also, radio doesn’t suit many creative teams. It demands very

intelligent writing and it’s very risky. When it works, it works very

very well but when it doesn’t, you really know about it.’



Trevor Beattie, the creative director of TBWA, says he felt a certain

amount of deja vu when he heard Howell’s comments. ‘Yes, he’s right. I

don’t think enough people care about radio - that’s the trouble. Radio

is appalling and it needn’t be. But we’ve been saying it for ten years

now - that’s the depressing thing,’ he comments.



‘Howell is in a very good position to talk about this because his agency

has produced brilliant radio work. I was on a radio awards committee

last year and along with the Boost campaign, the Howell Henry ‘apply

Tango’ work stood out a mile.



‘The impetus to change things has to come from the agencies themselves -

the awards people are doing their best to raise the profile of the

medium but they can only deal with what they are given in terms of

creative quality.



‘Yes, radio is regarded as the short straw in creative departments.

Creative directors do share a certain amount of responsibility there,

but the main problem is that it’s non-visual. You can have the best

awards in the world but you can’t put radio ads in an annual, you can’t

put them on the wall. Once they’ve been played, they’re gone. I don’t

know what you can do about that.’



Become a member of Campaign from just £45 a quarter

Get the very latest news and insight from Campaign with unrestricted access to campaignlive.co.uk ,plus get exclusive discounts to Campaign events

Become a member

Looking for a new job?

Get the latest creative jobs in advertising, media, marketing and digital delivered directly to your inbox each day.

Create an Alert Now

Partner content

Share

1 Job description: Digital marketing executive

Digital marketing executives oversee the online marketing strategy for their organisation. They plan and execute digital (including email) marketing campaigns and design, maintain and supply content for the organisation's website(s).