Ryanair's 'Bye bye Thomas Cook' ad overstepped mark, rules ASA
By Daniel Farey-Jones, campaignlive.co.uk, Wednesday, 07 March 2012 12:01AM
The ASA has criticised Ryanair's press ads that mocked a rival's financial troubles with the headline "Bye bye Thomas Cook", ruling them misleading and denigrating.
The series of three ads attracted 15 complaints to the Advertising Standards Authority, though not from Thomas Cook, covering four different counts, of which two were upheld.
The ads were run at the height of Thomas Cook's financial difficulties near the end of November last year, when poor trading forced the tour operator to borrow £100m.
The ads appeared in the Daily Express, the Oldham Evening Chronicle and Scotland on Sunday.
Although Ryanair was not the only company to run ads referencing Thomas Cook's troubles – Thomson put out one to underline it was "in great shape" despite "another holiday company experiencing turbulence" – its tone was more robust.
All Ryanair’s ads quoted two extracts from news stories on the Daily Mail website – "Thomas Cook in dire straits …" and "… accumulated debts of nearly £1bn". Other text stated: "Book Ryanair. Over three billion in cash reserves."
One ad also ran the words, "Ryanair – guaranteed to keep flying this Christmas", "We're financially secure" and "Ryanair – guaranteed to keep flying".
Ryanair contested the complaints but the ASA said the heading "Bye bye Thomas Cook", pictured alongside the newspaper headlines, would lead consumers to believe that Thomas Cook was likely to go into administration and was therefore a risky choice.
It also considered the line "Ryanair – guaranteed to keep flying this Christmas" implied Thomas Cook would cease trading by Christmas 2011.
The ASA ruled the ads broke rules on responsibility, misleading advertising, comparisons with identifiable competitors and imitation and denigration.
A Thomas Cook spokesman confirmed it did not submit a complaint to the ASA but declined to comment further.
The ASA adjudication is the second against Ryanair this year.
Follow Daniel Farey-Jones on Twitter @danfareyjones
This article was first published on campaignlive.co.uk
- PR Assistant / Junior PR Account Executive AF Selection £15,000 - £17,000 depending on experience, Nottingham, Nottinghamshire
- ACCOUNT DIRECTOR for Brand Agency - FREELANCE Royds Raphael Day rate c£275-£300, London (Central), London (Greater)
- ACCOUNT MANAGER - Branding Agency - FREELANCE Royds Raphael c£150-£170+ day rate depending on experience , London (Central), London (Greater)
- Brand Strategist / Planner - FREELANCE Royds Raphael £350-£450 day rate, London (Central), London (Greater)
- BUSINESS DEVELOPMENT MANAGER - Brand Comms Agency Royds Raphael £35K-£50K+bonus+bens, London (Central), London (Greater)
- ZenithOptimedia loses £200m O2 business to Havas Media without a pitch
- Doctor Who online game gets kids coding
- Philips launches juicer video campaign with Louis Smith
- Currys PC World launches brand campaign ahead of Christmas
- Argos releases second ad in its latest strategy
- A JWT tribute to its Oxo mum: Lynda Bellingham