Backbite

If I were Lowe Howard-Spink and I were asked to pitch for a pounds 25 million telecoms account in a shortlist comprising Leagas Delaney, J. Walter Thompson, BMP DDB and Shelf Wobblers Inc of Leamington Spa, I wouldn’t hesitate before refusing to enter the fray. The winner is sure to be Shelf Wobbers Inc, natch.

If I were Lowe Howard-Spink and I were asked to pitch for a pounds

25 million telecoms account in a shortlist comprising Leagas Delaney, J.

Walter Thompson, BMP DDB and Shelf Wobblers Inc of Leamington Spa, I

wouldn’t hesitate before refusing to enter the fray. The winner is sure

to be Shelf Wobbers Inc, natch.



I exaggerate, of course, but something like this happened last week.



Cable & Wireless Communications, the client with the yellow personality

and the deep purse, lined up four agencies to pitch for its launch

campaign this autumn. They were Saatchi & Saatchi, Bartle Bogle Hegarty,

HHCL & Partners and Rapier Stead & Bowden.



’Know thy readers’ is the first rule of magazine editing, so Campaign

last week dutifully described the appointment of Rapier as a shock (it

certainly was to one of our competitors who tipped Saatchis as the

victor) but I’m not so sure.



The key lies in the client’s comment about Rapier winning ’because of

its approach to the account as well as to its creativity’. If it were

just creativity in the dinosaur sense of the word, well, we can be sure

that Rapier would be off the list quicker than you could say relational

database. But, protest as they might, ad agencies are not exactly known

for their forward-thinking approach to multi-media campaigns or

advertising to small businesses.



Perhaps Rapier and HHCL had more of a sporting chance than BBH and

Saatchis because they’d worked with the client before. As a result, the

appointment has been post-rationalised by some observers into ’Oh well,

it was a stitch-up’, but the fact is that the decider was Rapier’s Big

Idea - and its mixture of strategic analysis, media choices and gut

creative instinct was bigger and better than the others. Tell that to

your friends and family in adland.



Topics

Before commenting please read our rules for commenting on articles.

If you see a comment you find offensive, you can flag it as inappropriate. In the top right-hand corner of an individual comment, you will see 'flag as inappropriate'. Clicking this prompts us to review the comment. For further information see our rules for commenting on articles.

comments powered by Disqus