CRAFT: CRAFT SECRETS; Dorlands chooses the natural look for Superdrug ‘videos’

Video diary ads are fun to watch and make financial sense. John Tylee reports

Video diary ads are fun to watch and make financial sense. John Tylee


Lana Turner may have caught Hollywood’s eye while waiting tables but

whoever heard of being offered the chance of TV fame when you’ve just

popped out of Superdrug clutching your plastic bag full of hairspray,

styling mousse and nail varnish?

Admittedly, this search for a star didn’t match the one for Gone with

the Wind. Nor was the budget of Spielberg-like proportions.

Nevertheless, the 300 people picked out formed the raw material for a

piece of British advertising history and a unique experiment in ‘DIY’

commercials shot with no script, no director, no film crew and with

nobody present from either the agency or the client.

Instead, the chosen few had video recorders installed in their homes,

were shown how to operate them and asked to talk to them each day for

two-and-a-half weeks about life, love and eyeliners.

The creative strategy, devised by Superdrug’s agency, Bates Dorland, was

born out of research showing that the retailer’s championing of low

prices - and particularly its battles with fine fragrance houses - had a

strong resonance with consumers.

What better way to harness that appeal, suggested the agency, than by

adopting the ‘video diaries’ technique and letting Superdrug’s customers

speak for themselves?

A Dorlands team led by Chips Hardy, the creative director on the

business, tested the idea using five agency secretaries. Even allowing

for the fact that the women knew about the ad business and what they

were expected to do, Hardy was excited enough by the results to seek out

a suitable director.

The choice was Martin Head, of Daryll Tate Associates, who combined

experience of TV documentary making with good casting skills. His

talents were to be crucial as the original 300 punters were pared down

to 12.

The first stage involved sifting through biographies and reducing the

list to reflect Superdrug’s core market - young girls and women with


The final selection, made after a series of home visits by Head and his

crew, was aimed at finding the people who seemed likely to be most at

ease with the video recorder. The team also had to weed out those who

looked as though they might threaten the honesty and freshness of the

films with over-the-top performances.

The result was almost 100 hours of footage, all of which was viewed by

Head, Hardy and the the copywriter, David Prideaux. The best material

was ‘so good it almost jumped out at you’, he says.

One example is the long-suffering lady who confides that ‘my husband’s

walking down the stairs with no clothes on and I’m not batting an eyelid

because he looks so disgusting’. As Prideaux says: ‘You couldn’t get a

performance like that if it was prompted.’

And the cost? About pounds 250,000 for a dozen films - equivalent to

what you’d normally pay for one ad featuring that ubiquitous model

tossing her silken mane.

Become a member of Campaign from just £46 a quarter

Get the very latest news and insight from Campaign with unrestricted access to ,plus get exclusive discounts to Campaign events

Become a member

Looking for a new job?

Get the latest creative jobs in advertising, media, marketing and digital delivered directly to your inbox each day.

Create an Alert Now

Partner content