EDITORIAL: Haines reflects the ad industry's state

After the whirlwind that was Rupert Howell, the IPA this week opted

for Bruce Haines's more tranquil approach when it formally chose its

president for the next two years. The selection of the IPA leader

doesn't always reflect advertising's prevailing climate. More often it's

a case of finding somebody who commands not only sufficient respect, but

is time-rich enough to devote anything up to two days a week to the job.

A tough brief.

Somehow, though, recent circumstances have contrived to throw up

presidential candidates who seem to fit the times. When Howell took on

the task in 1999 he was the perfect cheerleader for a business

bedevilled by collective insecurity, solipsism and defensiveness.

Little matter that he was a master of self-hype. He believed

passionately that the industry should be proud of what it did and of its

importance to the economy, and his public advocacy stiffened sinews

during an important period. What's more, Howell's swashbuckling seemed

in tune with an industry riding on the back of a booming economy and

incomes fuelled by dotcoms.

Equally, Haines's less flamboyant style may be in keeping with a

business now needing to pause for breath. Whether or not recession is

about to administer the cold sponge is an open question. Even if the UK

is insulated from the US downturn, problems in the world's biggest ad

market will translate into reduced spends here.

It is apposite that the industry spokesman should be somebody with

Haines's calm authority. He neither talks bullshit nor tolerates it, and

is an experienced manager at an agency that has always kept creativity

at the top of its agenda. If Howell speaks from the heart, Haines speaks

from the head. He champions creativity because he believes it to be the

most important weapon in any agency's armoury.

Howell helped give the industry back its self-belief which, in turn,

encouraged clients to invest in their brands. It will be up to Haines to

help ensure that self-belief is sustained if times get tougher.

Nor must the IPA allow clients to ignore the body of evidence showing

that companies that maintained spending behind their brands during a

downturn will be best placed to profit from an upswing.


Before commenting please read our rules for commenting on articles.

If you see a comment you find offensive, you can flag it as inappropriate. In the top right-hand corner of an individual comment, you will see 'flag as inappropriate'. Clicking this prompts us to review the comment. For further information see our rules for commenting on articles.

comments powered by Disqus