MEDIA FORUM: Is the Sun poised to go upmarket after Higgins? Has the Sun lost its way? It has certainly lost its editor, Stuart Higgins, who was kicked upstairs last week. Strategic differences, allegedly Senior management were said to want fewer bare bre

’What a week,’ Stuart Higgins joked, just before being banged out.

’What a week,’ Stuart Higgins joked, just before being banged


’First Geri, then Gazza, now me.’ Not that Geri Spice or Gazza got the

banging treatment - not that we know of. Banging out is an old Fleet

Street tradition reserved for departing journalists.

Still, there are some similarities in the fates of the three tabloid

stars. The Sun, minus Higgins, is now an institution with uncertain and

potentially shaky prospects - though compared with the Spice Girls’

charisma rating or England’s World Cup hopes, its future isn’t quite so


But, as with Geri and Gazza, Higgins’ departure was also the occasion

for expressions of sorrow and disbelief. The banging out was, by all

accounts, particularly loud - he was a popular editor. Higgins can also

probably count himself lucky that, in the mass market, all eyes have

been on the Mirror, whose circulation has dropped so far that it could

soon be overtaken by the Daily Mail.

But the Mirror’s sales slide (3 per cent year on year in April to

2,293,269) has been nothing to the Sun’s (3,714,666 in April, down 6 per

cent year on year). That hasn’t exactly gone down a storm with senior

News International executives. And, according to insiders, they have

become increasingly alarmed at what they perceive as attempts by the

Mirror to move slightly upmarket.

The Sun’s last ad campaign, courtesy of TBWA Simons Palmer, toyed with

something similar. It dumped the bouncy, in-yer-face ’no Sun, no fun’

for a touchy-feely spot ’dedicated to the people of Britain’. In theory,

the product itself was to be tweaked so it could live up to the


Innovations, like asking Page Three girls to keep their bras on, for


Higgins, apparently, was having none of it.

Which is why he was kicked upstairs. His replacement, David Yelland, is

an unknown quantity with a business journalism background. Is he being

brought in to implement a new agenda? Is that what the Sun needs? Has

the Mirror really moved upmarket? Does it hold the strategic high

ground? And, more pertinently, has the Sun lost its way?

Christine Walker, the managing partner of Walker Media, doesn’t believe

notions of up- or downmarket have anything to do with this. The Mirror

has merely returned to a more intelligent, current affairs-driven news

agenda. The celebrity gossip and tittle tattle doesn’t dominate in quite

the way it used to - and still does at the Sun.

She says: ’The front page of the Mirror has improved immeasurably

recently - and that’s such an important driver for the success of a


It has been generating exclusives that have, in turn, generated a lot of

interest from other media. You get the feeling that the Mirror is more

vibrant than the Sun these days. I don’t think it’s anything to do with

going upmarket. It’s just hotter. It’s a better package. If you look at

the most recent ABC figures, the sector as a whole is under pressure but

the Mirror is holding out better.’

But what has happened to the caring, sharing ad campaign? Colin

Gottlieb, managing partner of Manning Gottlieb Media, would like to

know. ’It’s interesting that the Sun’s new advertising was all about

supposedly softer 90s values as opposed to its previous up-yer-bum

approach. But I think that newspaper publishing is getting sucked into

the same sort of mindset as many other business sectors - there is a

constant feeling that the ground is about to shift under its feet.

People these days are constantly looking for a new positioning.’

But Gottlieb doesn’t believe the Sun should worry about the Mirror’s

positioning: ’The Mirror has been and still is pretty schizophrenic. I

think the problem is that we’re seeing that sense of schizophrenia

invading the Sun too. For my money, Higgins was right to resist a big

shift in the positioning of the Sun. I think it would be dangerous if it

lost its fun, upbeat approach. And where are they really going to take

it? I think the readership base knows what it likes. It would be a shame

if News International - once the most confident of publishers - lost

confidence now.’

He is not alone in that fear. Chris Shaw, the joint managing director of

Universal McCann, is also sceptical: ’I think the whole thing about the

Sun going upmarket is bizarre, frankly. If it’s true, they are

over-reacting to the circulation decline. The Sun is still the

biggest-selling daily in the country and it is still a successful

formula. Why on earth would they want to move it upmarket? I take that

to mean that they’d want to shift it towards the Daily Mail. But look at

the figures. There isn’t the circulation to be had in the mid market.

And whatever they think is happening at the Mirror, it certainly isn’t

perceived as having shifted anywhere.’

But surely all papers have their era - perhaps the Sun has had its


There’s a new mood in the country. And a Labour government. The Sun’s

soaraway fortunes in the 80s and early 90s were surely all to do with

the fact that it caught the mood of the Thatcherite times. Those days

are gone. Paul Mukherjee, the press buying director of MindShare, agrees

that politics could be at the root of Higgins’ decision to move on.

’What the Mirror has done is become a paper opposed to the Government.

Whereas the Sun’s political line to back Labour was chosen by Rupert


That cuts against the instincts of the people there and it can’t have

been easy for Higgins in particular. Changing the paper’s outlook has to

be difficult. They’ve also lost their main source of big front-page

stories - Princess Diana.’

And he also thinks it’s interesting that the ’dedicated to the people of

Britain’ ad hasn’t been seen for a while. ’The rumour is that Murdoch

has told them to drop it and go back to price promotion. And maybe he’s

right in believing there is a direct correlation between price and


After all, if you go back a few years, before all the price wars, the

Sun was selling only 3.4 million.

’As for dropping the Page Three girls, the big question is whether you

can be a tabloid paper and be irreverent while being an editorially led

product at the same time. I don’t think anyone knows the answer to



Become a member of Campaign from just £46 a quarter

Get the very latest news and insight from Campaign with unrestricted access to ,plus get exclusive discounts to Campaign events

Become a member

Looking for a new job?

Get the latest creative jobs in advertising, media, marketing and digital delivered directly to your inbox each day.

Create an Alert Now

Partner content