Pick & Turkey league (18 March 2011)

Ian Darby is a big McDonald's fan after seeing their latest ad but Jeremy Lee isn't laughing after watching Sainsbury's Comic Relief ads.

McDonald's 'children' by Leo Burnett
McDonald's 'children' by Leo Burnett

PICK OF THE WEEK

Ian Darby feels energised after watching Leo Burnett’s latest TV spot for McDonald’s: "Leo Burnett’s work for McDonald’s in the past year or two has been back to its best and this TV ad, to promote the sale of a new fruit-based Fanta drink, continues that trend. The performance from the ebullient children is thoroughly charming and it’s beautifully shot and edited." The ad was written and art directed by Caroline Rawlings and Chris Birch, and directed by Neil Gorringe through Moxie Pictures.

TURKEY OF THE WEEK

Jeremy Lee despairs over Abbott Mead Vickers BBDO’s ad for Sainsbury’s: "This spot promoting Sainsbury’s efforts for the enforced hilarity of Red Nose Day irritates me on so many levels. Its otherwise credible spokesman Jamie Oliver promises that ‘the more red noses we buy, the sillier we’ll get’. This silliness consists of making its staff dress up in fancy dress. Personally, I’d rather Sainsbury’s improved its trading terms with its suppliers. But perhaps that would be too silly."

 

Pick and Turkey League 2011
Pick tally Agency Brand Campaigns
       
1 RKCR/Y&R  Land Rover Claynation
1 Fallon  BBC Radio 4 Film Season
1 JWT London  Kit Kat crane
2 Wieden + Kennedy London  Lurpak Kitchen Odyssey
  Cravendale Cats with Thumbs
1  Publicis
 Renault  Va va voom
1  Mother
Stella Artois The Train
1  iris
Quit UK The End
1  Leo Burnett
McDonald's children
       




Turkey tally      
1 Longines in-house  Longines Dolce Vita
1 Koala  Mazuma Mobile Post-Christmas
1 Ogilvy & Mather  Dove no white marks
1 Karmarama  Colman's Season & Shake
1 McCann London  Bisto Promise
2 AMV BBDO  Gillette Proglide Challenge
    Sainsbury's Comic Relief
1 JWT London  Aero Caramel daffodils
1 Fallon  T-Mobile and Orange Posters
1 TBWA\Los Angeles  Denta Stix Dentures