Specsavers claims victory after two-year battle with Asda

Specsavers is claiming victory in a legal wrangle with Asda over an ad campaign the supermarket giant ran for its opticians using a "spec savings at Asda" strapline.

Specsavers: 'rollercoaster' campaign
Specsavers: 'rollercoaster' campaign

The Court of Appeal ruled that Asda's strapline and use of a double-ellipse logo was similar to Specsavers' and an infringement of trademark.

Family-owned Specsavers said it intends to pursue a damage claim against Walmart-owned Asda and has taunted the supermarket with a press release titled 'Asda Shouldn't Have Gone to Specsavers'.

It is not clear what maximum potential sum for damages Asda could be liable for.

Asda is claiming the ruling was a "score draw" after the Court of Appeal rejected one of the legal bases of Specsavers' case, which claimed the campaign had caused customer confusion.

Some issues relating to how important an issue the colour of the logo is and how often Specsavers used its logo without words have been referred to the Court of Justice of the European Union for clarification.

Dame May Perkins, founder of Specsavers, said: "Asda was deliberately mimicking our advertising and were well aware of the risks they were running.

"When we first raised this with Asda, their response was to issue a press release saying that we would have to sue them as they would not back down … so we did.

"It has taken years and a lot of hard work to build up our identity and we will rigorously defend our brand against any infringers."

Asda has responded by issuing a statement accusing Specsavers of making "a spectacle of themselves by refusing to understand a very simple point – we're better value than them."

It continued: "No tricks or gimmicks – just low prices – any amount of legal wrangling isn't going to change the fact that customers want price transparency."

Specsavers claims victory after two-year battle with Asda

Follow Matthew Chapman at @mattchapmanuk

Become a member of Campaign

Get the very latest news and insight from Campaign with unrestricted access to campaignlive.co.uk , plus get exclusive discounts to Campaign events

Become a member

Looking for a new job?

Get the latest creative jobs in advertising, media, marketing and digital delivered directly to your inbox each day.

Create an alert now

Partner content