Watch out adland, Silicon Valley wants your people, as well as your money

Nicola Mendelsohn's move from Karmarama to Facebook continues a worrying brain drain for advertising, says Daniel Joseph, director at The App Business.

Nichola Mendelsohn leaves Karmarama for Facebook
Nichola Mendelsohn leaves Karmarama for Facebook

When I saw the news about Nicola Mendelsohn getting the top job at Facebook EMEA, what struck me most wasn't that fact that she's another 'Super-mum' who can boss it in business. It was that the UK's beloved 'adland' had lost an incredibly high-profile, high-value leader to the world of technology, and nobody seems to be going the other way.

Sure, this isn't the first time a person from adland has moved to a high-profile tech company (Google has snapped up legions of ex-advertising people). But Nicola Mendelsohn is the most high-profile mover and she is certainly the first to land the top job.

For me, the move squarely brings into focus just how serious technology companies are about embracing, acquiring and learning new marketing skills to successfully grow their businesses. This is entirely logical and sensible: technology companies, in order to monetize their products, need to understand how to get brands to pay for access to them. Who better to do that than Nicola Mendelshohn, with her deep industry insight, client long-list and golden touch? And they are deadly serious about it. They are willing to let someone, with no technology experience, step in and run the whole thing, because they know that she will know best. £934m in revenue, entrusted to what some might see as an 'outsider'.

However, this open-mindeness seems to be on just one side of the fence, and the skills and knowledge migration sadly seems to be just one way. How many advertising companies have acknowledged that they really don't have a clue when it comes to technology and have reached out to a genuine technology person to run their business? I can't think of any at market, agency or holding company level. And this seems a lot less logical. Just as technology needs to get advertising, advertising needs to get technology, and lightening fast.

From my personal experience of working on both sides of the fence, it's not that the tech types won't understand the intricacies of advertising even if adland would love to think so. (And what they don't understand will probably make them stronger anyway). And it's unlikely to be the money: advertising still makes plenty of it and can still write super-sized cheques when it needs to. So my hypothesis is a little more depressing:

Nobody in adland seems to have the courage to admit that they really don't get it, that the old model needs genuine outside help to evolve and fix, and to empower someone from a world they don't understand to run their businesses. And I think that's going to cost advertising dearly. (Oh, and an army of creative technologists or innovation heads does not count. They aren't deeply experienced technology people, and they're not running the place).

Selfishly, from our company - The App Business - perspective, long may this continue. We've always believed that our ability to combine an understanding of brands and businesses with deep in-house technical expertise is something clients would find increasingly valuable. That's why over half of the company are software engineers who can actually build products and sweat code.

But for adland's sake, someone out there has to sum up the courage to make a proper counter-raid on Silicon Valley or Silicon Roundabout, put them at the top of their business and watch what good happens. I'd be amazed if it didn't create incredible value and steal a march on the competition.

Daniel Joseph is director of The App Busines

Become a member of Campaign from just £51 a quarter

Get the very latest news and insight from Campaign with unrestricted access to ,plus get exclusive discounts to Campaign events

Become a member

Looking for a new job?

Get the latest creative jobs in advertising, media, marketing and digital delivered directly to your inbox each day.

Create an alert now

Partner content